Disclaimer: This content was generated using AI. While we strive for accuracy, please verify critical information with official sources.
Sources: National Vulnerability Database, CISA KEV, Exploit-DB
CVE-2024-56136 Overview
CVE-2024-56136 is an information disclosure vulnerability in Zulip Server, an open-source team chat platform. The flaw affects Zulip Server versions 7.0 and later when a single server hosts multiple organizations. An unauthenticated attacker can send authentication requests and observe server responses to determine whether a given email address is registered to a user in another organization on the same server. The issue is tracked under GitHub Security Advisory GHSA-5xg8-xhfj-4hm6 and classified as [CWE-200] Exposure of Sensitive Information to an Unauthorized Actor. Zulip Server 9.4 and the main branch resolve the issue.
Critical Impact
Unauthenticated remote attackers can enumerate valid user email addresses across organizations hosted on the same Zulip Server, enabling targeted phishing and account reconnaissance.
Affected Products
- Zulip Server 7.0 and later (prior to 9.4)
- Multi-organization Zulip Server deployments
- Self-hosted Zulip installations exposed to the public internet
Discovery Timeline
- 2025-01-16 - CVE-2024-56136 published to NVD
- 2026-06-17 - Last updated in NVD database
Technical Details for CVE-2024-56136
Vulnerability Analysis
The vulnerability resides in Zulip's authentication flow in zerver/views/auth.py. When a user attempts to authenticate against an organization (subdomain) where their email does not have an account, the backend returned an InvalidSubdomainError if that email address existed in a different organization on the same server. By contrast, email addresses with no account anywhere returned a generic AuthenticationFailedError. The response differentiation allowed an unauthenticated client to probe arbitrary email addresses and infer their presence on the server.
This cross-organization enumeration primarily impacts multi-tenant Zulip deployments, including Zulip Cloud-style installations where tenant isolation is a baseline expectation. The leaked information facilitates targeted phishing campaigns, credential-stuffing against known valid accounts, and reconnaissance of internal corporate groups sharing infrastructure.
Root Cause
The root cause is improper error handling that exposes authentication state intended only for internal server logs. The invalid_subdomain return value was never meant to reach end users because its presence confirms an account exists under a different subdomain for the submitted email. The confidentiality impact is reflected in the EPSS score of 0.571% (46th percentile).
Attack Vector
An unauthenticated attacker submits login requests to a target Zulip server's subdomain using candidate email addresses. The attacker observes whether the server returns the invalid-subdomain error versus a generic authentication failure, inferring account existence across organizations. No credentials, user interaction, or privileges are required.
if return_data.get("password_reset_needed"):
return PasswordResetRequiredError()
if return_data.get("invalid_subdomain"):
- raise InvalidSubdomainError
+ # We must not report invalid_subdomain here; that value is intended only for informing server logs,
+ # and should never be exposed to end users, since it would leak whether there exists
+ # an account in a different organization with the same email address.
+ return AuthenticationFailedError()
return AuthenticationFailedError()
Source: Zulip security patch commit c6334a7
Detection Methods for CVE-2024-56136
Indicators of Compromise
- Repeated unauthenticated POST requests to /accounts/login/ or /api/v1/fetch_api_key from a single source IP cycling through many distinct email addresses.
- HTTP 400 or JSON responses containing invalid_subdomain errors in web server access logs on vulnerable Zulip Server versions.
- Abnormally high ratio of failed authentication attempts spanning multiple organization subdomains hosted on the same server.
Detection Strategies
- Review Zulip application logs for the invalid_subdomain return path and correlate with source IP and request volume.
- Deploy rate-limiting and anomaly detection on authentication endpoints to flag enumeration patterns.
- Compare response bodies and timing between authentication attempts for known-valid versus known-invalid emails to confirm exposure on untested servers.
Monitoring Recommendations
- Alert on bursts of login attempts targeting more than N unique email addresses per source within a short window.
- Monitor Zulip server version strings across the fleet and flag any instance running 7.0 through 9.3.
- Ingest Zulip authentication logs into a centralized SIEM for cross-subdomain correlation and retention.
How to Mitigate CVE-2024-56136
Immediate Actions Required
- Upgrade all Zulip Server instances to version 9.4 or the current main branch build.
- Audit multi-organization deployments for signs of email enumeration in historical access logs.
- Enforce rate limiting on authentication endpoints at the reverse proxy or WAF layer.
Patch Information
The fix is included in Zulip Server 9.4 and is applied via commit c6334a765b1e6d71760e4a3b32ae5b8367f2ed4d. The patch modifies zerver/views/auth.py to return a generic AuthenticationFailedError() instead of raising InvalidSubdomainError, ensuring the invalid_subdomain state is retained only in server-side logs. Refer to GHSA-5xg8-xhfj-4hm6 for the vendor advisory.
Workarounds
- No official workarounds exist per the Zulip security advisory; upgrading is required.
- As a compensating control, restrict authentication endpoint access to known IP ranges or VPN users where feasible.
- Deploy a WAF rule to normalize authentication error responses before they reach external clients.
# Upgrade Zulip Server to a patched release (9.4 or newer)
/home/zulip/deployments/current/scripts/upgrade-zulip-from-git 9.4
# Verify installed version post-upgrade
/home/zulip/deployments/current/scripts/get-django-setting ZULIP_VERSION
Disclaimer: This content was generated using AI. While we strive for accuracy, please verify critical information with official sources.
Sources: National Vulnerability Database, CISA KEV, Exploit-DB

